A New York court recently issued a significant decision favoring the plaintiff in a wrongful death lawsuit. This firm’s legal team, Justin W. Gray, Esq. and Kelly A. Kline, Esq. of Maynard, O’Connor, Smith & Catalinotto, LLP, represents the plaintiff as Administrator of the decedent’s estate and successfully secured rulings that establish liability and protect assets while the case proceeds toward a determination of damages.
Key Rulings in Plaintiff’s Favor
Liability Established (Partial Summary Judgment Granted)
The court granted the plaintiff partial summary judgment on liability, meaning the defendant’s responsibility for the death has been established as a matter of law and will not be re-litigated in the civil case.
The court found that the facts underlying the wrongful death claim were conclusively established through the related criminal proceedings, including the defendant’s sworn admissions. As a result, the case now moves forward primarily on the issue of damages.
Defendant’s Attempt to Dismiss Damages Rejected
The defendant sought summary judgment arguing there was no proof the plaintiff could establish damages, even if liability were proven. The court denied that request.
The court found the defendant’s arguments were premature and that questions of fact remain as to recoverable damages, including pecuniary loss and funeral expenses.
The court also recognized that the record contains evidence raising issues regarding conscious pain and suffering and fear of impending death, based on circumstances described in the decision.
In addition, the court noted that the conduct at issue could support punitive damages, given the nature of the wrongdoing.
Discovery Can Move Forward and Defendant Must Appear
The court lifted the discovery stay that had previously limited discovery from the defendant while related criminal proceedings were pending.
With the stay lifted, discovery may proceed and the defendant is required to sit for a deposition in accordance with applicable civil procedure rules.
This ruling is an important step toward developing the evidence needed to fully evaluate damages and financial issues relevant to collection.
Asset Transfers Restrained Through Injunctions
The court granted preliminary injunctions restricting the transfer or disbursement of certain assets, finding the plaintiff demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits, a risk of irreparable harm without injunctive relief, and that the equities favor the plaintiff.
The court expressed concern about the dissipation of substantial assets connected to an estate in which the defendant had a significant beneficial interest, including large disbursements made shortly before the plaintiff sought court intervention.
The court also addressed the transfer and sale of real property and ordered restraints on remaining funds derived from that sale.
Additionally, the court imposed restrictions on further transfers by the defendant, while allowing limited exceptions for necessary carrying costs and certain capped expenditures, unless otherwise permitted by further court order.
What This Means Going Forward
With liability decided, discovery moving forward, and asset restraints in place, the case will now proceed toward determining the amount of damages owed and potential resolution through settlement or trial. In addition, once liability has been determined, any eventual judgment may also include interest as permitted under New York law, which can increase the total amount recoverable depending on the timing of resolution and entry of judgment.
Disclaimer: This post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
This day and age, liability waivers are everywhere. From amusement parks to gym memberships to school field trips, many people sign waivers of liability, hidden away in the fine print, without even realizing it. But what happens on the off-chance you do sustain a personal injury and discovered that you signed a waiver? Did you really sign away your legal rights to sue and pursue compensation for your injuries?
Unfortunately, 
The construction industry is a dangerous industry where accidents happen far too often. Negligence of safety measures by way of general contractors and construction site owners can lead to worksite accidents like construction site falls, machinery accidents, and electrocutions.
What is No-Fault Insurance? What Does it Cover?
You normally wouldn’t think of winter as prime motorcycle riding season, but for some motorcycle drivers—and especially where we live in Upstate New York—winter is just another season to ride and enjoy your motorcycle.
When you buy a product from a store, you expect that item to do what it’s intended to do–not injure you. Defective products injure thousands of consumers every year, and unfortunately this happens across industries, from automotive, to medical devices, to children’s toys, and more.
